Apple, Palm hear privately from USB-IF on iTunes spat, involvement unlikely (update: the Forum’s not pleased)

Sep 22nd 2009
No Comments
respond
trackback

Hello there! If you are new here, you might want to subscribe to the RSS feed for updates on this topic.

The very public fight between Palm and Apple to allow the Pre to sync directly to iTunes (without just… you know, doing it the same way as everyone else) is showing no signs of slowing down, with Palm continuing to pursue every angle it can to rile up Cupertino — most recently taking the battle up to the USB Implementers’ Forum in an effort to stop Apple from restricting iTunes usage by the hardware’s Vendor ID. Hard to say what ended up going down behind closed doors, but on an official level, the USB-IF is issuing a terse statement that it “communicated its position on the matter to both companies” and won’t be speaking further on the issue “at this time.” We’ll see if anything ends up changing on the software side from the conversation, but separately, the Forum has mentioned to us that it considers this a member-to-member concern — so in all likelihood, they’re taking a hands-off approach.

Update: Digital Daily has come away with a very, very different story from the actual leaked communication, and it turns out that the USB-IF has actually sided against Palm on two different fronts. First, the Forum has told Palm that it doesn’t see how blocking Palm’s Vendor ID from accessing iTunes violates its policies; and second — this might be the big one — Palm’s actually riled up the Forum by saying that it’ll be using Apple’s Vendor ID on the Pre going forward. It wants a clarification of Palm’s “intent” within a week, saying such a move would be contrary to the rules and regs set out for the proper use of USB. At this point the question becomes, how many companies and industry bodies is Palm willing to piss off to keep iTunes working exactly the way it wants?

Filed under: Cellphones, Handhelds